| PL | Athlete | Team | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Freeman, Ryan | Indiana TC | 40.58m |
| 2 | Buie, Nas | Carmel Stallions | 33.74m |
| 3 | Smith, James | Unattached | 32.40m |
| 4 | Minges, Clark | Unattached | 31.99m |
| 5 | Ash, Payton | Merrillville TC | 29.49m |
| 6 | Roberts, Ashton | Carmel Stallions | 28.30m |
| 7 | Bertucci, Derek | Let It Fly Throwing | 27.50m |
| 8 | Pullins, Brett | Let It Fly Throwing | 27.37m |
| 9 | Fuller, Stephen | Fishers Fire | 23.91m |
| 10 | Goddin, Robert | Indiana TC | 21.67m |
| Weingartner, Pierce | Unattached | ND |